Selection
At Neal’s Yard Dairy, our ambition is to sell the British and Irish cheeses we like best. That means identifying interesting, characterful or authentic varieties, but it also means selecting the individual cheeses that we want to sell. Some of our cheesemakers are making the same cheese almost every day, so in any given years, as many as 350 'vintages' may emerge from the dairy, each of which will differ slightly in character. Some will meet our exacting standards, others won’t. Only very rarely would we take more than half of a cheesemaker’s annual output. This means that our standards are never compromised – we want only the cheeses we like the best.
The importance of getting the selection right is made even more acute by the time and resource that goes into maturing our cheeses. Discovering after several months of effort that a particular day’s production doesn’t meet our needs would be extremely wasteful, which is why identifying the profile of a cheese when it is young is so crucial. When we select a cheese, we are judging not just how it appears right there in the moment, but how it will evolve through every stage of its maturation, over the weeks, months or even years to come.
We visit each cheesemaker on a regular basis to sample their cheeses with them and select which ones we want to buy, employing our full range of senses to determine those that are best for us. First we smell the cheese. Then we may briefly knead it between the fingers to look for clues in texture and structure. If it’s a little too dry at a young age, it may break down as it ages; if it’s too wet, the maturation process may prove problematic. As we rub it with our fingers, the cheese warms up, releasing its aroma and bringing the flavours to life. Only then do we taste it. We judge its acidity, the length, strength and character of it flavours. We do the same thing again and again, often differentiating between numerous different vintages all made in the same month.